Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Manufacturing isn't coming back. Do you think your average American would put up with the conditions in a Chinese iPhone factory?


When I was 20, I worked washing dishes in restaurants. I applied for a job at a semiconductor manufacturer but didn't get it. I jumped at the opportunity when it came to work with electronics at a small shop. I would have tried manufacturing. But I don't know what "conditions" you're referring to.


Have you been in one? I have. It is not something I would want to do, but it is not as bad some low paying jobs in the US.

Sweatshops exist in China, but the top electronics manufacturers (mostly Taiwan-owned) have relatively good conditions.


That's the wrong question. Would they put up with the conditions in a US factory?

It's common to see negative opinions of manufacturing jobs here and on other tech sites. I've worked in one the UK, doing 12 hour long day and night shifts (as a lab tech; I now have a PhD). It was long and hard work, being on your feet around a huge complex collecting samples from all the stages in production and then analysing them to strict deadlines. But you know what, I had greater job satisfaction from doing that than any other job to date, including the position I have now at a university. When I left the factory gates at the end of a shift, I was done, and could head home and relax in the knowledge that I'd done a good job, done my bit to keep the site and production running, and made a small but net positive contribution to the world. And got paid a decent wage for it. And working on a site with a big workforce can be very friendly environment with a lots of camaraderie with everyone working to the same goal to keep production running. You can have a lot of fun while on the job, while also working hard. As a software developer in acadaemia, and I suspect for many software developers in general, work never ends. When I leave work, the unfinished problems and backlog of untackled problems don't go away, which when coupled with deadlines and team communication, admin etc., can lead to significant amounts of stress and unhappiness and depression which I never encountered before. I suspect the lack of physical activity also contributes. And working in an open plan office with everyone plugged into headphones and on IM all day is much less social; at times I think it's like working with zombies!

In the UK, factory workers have strong legal requirements for safe working conditions, limits on hours, union representation if desired, and a host of other protections. The US has less strong employment protections, but I understand health and safety rules and maximum work hours etc. are decent. But would people want to work in a modern purpose-built manufacturing facility in the US? Hell, yes. Working on something like that can give real meaning and purpose to one's life, to be doing something real that actually contributes something physical to the world. Even if you're a small cog in a giant machine. As you head out of the factory gates and see the stream of lorries heading out loaded with product, you know that without your work that shift, they wouldn't be going, and that can give you genuine satisfaction. Ask the millions of people who lost their factory jobs to offshoring if they would go back for an answer with real meaning. I strongly suspect you'd have a majority vote yes.

I know this might not be a popular opinion, but I'll say it anyway. Manufacturing is what made the UK and the US into industrial powerhouses, which lead directly to the prosperity and quality of life we have enjoyed for decades, and its rapid decline has lead to a steep decline of both for many people, and a whole host of social problems. While the idea that a service economy will take over has been strongly pushed on both sides of the pond, it's obvious to anyone with an ounce of common sense that this isn't self sustaining; these are not wealth-creating industries since unlike manufacturing, they only transfer existing wealth around.


Well said. I wish I could give you more than one upvote.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: